top of page

THE CMO IS NOT A MACHINE

Nov 2
5 min read

What an AI can run, what it cannot, and why racquet sports operators should care about the difference.


A LinkedIn post graphic titled The Claude CMO Department - an org chart with an AI CMO seated over seven desks - shown beside the words: A year of slop for your club, on schedule. Inside the Lines Advisory logo below.
The org chart from Ignacio Prieto's LinkedIn post. The panel on the right is mine.

Seven hundred and forty-two comments.


That was the count on the post the last time I looked. Most of them a single word: CMO.


The post was an org chart. At the top, in the seat where a chief marketing officer would sit, was an AI agent. Underneath it, seven desks. Paid. Content. Brand. Email. Landing pages. Positioning. Reporting. Six of the seven desks came with a count. Nine seats in three pods. Seventy-five post structures in eight families. A brand profile scored on nine checks and rebuilt to 100 out of 100. A sixty-minute audit. Nine skill files. A Monday memo with three rows.


Comment CMO, the graphic said.


WHAT THE POST NEVER SAYS

Read it twice and a pattern shows up. Every number in it counts an input. Posts. Seats. Files. Minutes. Rows. One of them counts a score the system gave its own work.


Not one number counts a business outcome.


No business where it has run is named. No revenue figure, no membership sold, no quarter described. He says the same shape runs his own marketing. What it has produced there, or anywhere you could check it, is not in the post. And the post never says what you receive when you comment - the working system, or a description of it.


I know, because I asked. I left a comment with the two questions that matter most. What do you actually get? And is this running inside a real business today? 48 hours later, crickets.

WHAT IS ACTUALLY BEING SOLD

At the top of the graphic sits a brand name. I looked it up.


The brand is an AI platform for paid advertising. One of the seven desks, sold as a product.


It has not launched. Its own website says more than fifty companies are on the waitlist. The same website says the platform is trusted by agencies and enterprise teams managing more than ten million euros in annual ad spend.


Both of those sentences are on the same page.


The part of the site meant to show the platform in action has no video in it. The placeholder text is still showing.


The org chart is for sale, too. The same brand sells the build itself - the skill files, the seventy-five structures, the nine GTM files - as a paid newsletter. Its own page promises subscribers the full build materials, and first access to the ads platform when it opens.


So the whole arrangement, end to end, is this. A company with an unlaunched ads tool drew an org chart, put an AI in the CMO seat, and made that chart the offer to any founder willing to type one word in the comments.


The chart sells a subscription. The subscription sells first access to the tool.


The post drew seven hundred and one comments. Type the word, and whatever comes back arrives in your inbox, where nobody else can read it. Mine asked two questions in public, where they could be answered in public.


As I write this, there is no public answer.


Behind the department is a subscription. Behind the subscription is a waitlist.


FULL DISCLOSURE

I am not writing this as someone who refuses the technology.


I work with an AI assistant every day, across everything I work on. Inside the Lines. Facility Ally. The client work, the projects, the teaching, the writing. It reads my inboxes before I do. It checks my calendar for collisions I would have walked into. It does the first pass on research and drafts, and it checks every number I use against the source it came from.


Business owners have a saying: work on the business, not in it. That is what the machinery does for me. It carries the in-the-business work - the sorting, the checking, the first passes - and hands me back the hours for the work only I can do. It has made me faster at all of it than I have ever been.


It has never made a decision for me.

Not a price. Not a client. Not a diagnosis. Not a strategy. Not an insight. Not a headline. Not a no. Every send waits for my yes.


His post sets the same rule, and states it in full. The rule that never breaks, he writes: the agent runs the machinery and I keep the calls. Budget, brand, and every send wait for my yes. The graphic ends with the same promise in five words. The calls stay yours.


On the rule, we do not disagree at all.


So the difference between his setup and mine is not the workflow. It is not who decides, either. By his own account, he decides.


The difference is what we call it.


He calls the machinery the CMO. I call it staff work, done at machine speed, in service of decisions a person still has to make and stand behind.


A man who keeps the calls has not handed over the seat. He is sitting in it, with better machinery underneath him than any CMO has ever had. That is a good story. It is just not the one the org chart tells.


A workflow is not a chief marketing officer. An org chart of tasks is not a seat. The seat exists for the moments the chart cannot cover - the call that costs real money, the room you have to read, the trade-off where someone senior has to pick a side and own what happens next.


WHY THIS LANDS IN RACQUET SPORTS

If you run a club, you already know why that post pulled more than seven hundred comments.


You are the marketing department. You are also membership, programming, events, and the person they call when the irrigation breaks. The idea of a department in a box, running your content and your email while you get back to the courts, is not a fantasy to you. It is Tuesday.


Here is what the button promises to do for that club.


It will produce. A year of posts, a season of emails, a landing page a week. It will do it on schedule, in volume, without a sick day. And it will produce exactly what the club already believes about itself, at scale.


If the club has decided who it is for, what it stands for, and why a member should choose it over the new courts opening four miles away, that production is leverage. Good decisions, multiplied.


If the club has not decided, the button multiplies the indecision. More content saying nothing, faster. The club four miles away buys the same button and runs the same structures. The industry calls what happens next language flattening. Two clubs, one voice - and the member cannot tell you apart. The weak spot was never output. Output is the one thing that just got cheap.


Growth creates pressure. Pressure finds the weak spot. In most clubs I work with, the weak spot is a decision nobody has made yet - about positioning, about price, about who the club is actually for. No desk in that org chart makes that decision. One of the seven is even named Positioning, and what it holds is nine files.


WHERE I LAND

Use the machinery. I do, every day, and I am not going back.


But keep the title honest. The day you believe the department in the box is your CMO is the day you stop doing the one part of the job that was ever the job.

Automate the machinery. Keep the seat honest.


If you are an operator heading into 2027 still trying to make those decisions - who you are for, what you stand for, where the growth actually comes from - that is the work I do. The Growth Pressure Review is free; I read every submission myself, and it starts there.


Go find your court.


Mike


P.S. Not a machine.

Comments


bottom of page