Is Your AI Leaking Club Revenue?
Updated: 5 days ago

Last week a post went around offering an "AI CMO" system. Type CMO in the comments and the system was yours.
750 people typed CMO.
It led to nothing. There was no system. Just 750 grown people in this industry, standing in line like lemmings at a cliff, hoping a machine was about to take marketing off their plate.

I wish that was the worst of it. A company in this business is giving clubs free websites, built by AI, to win their ad business.
A free website with none of the plumbing underneath it - no analytics set up, no tagging, no SEO - cannot sell anything, and nobody can prove what it did. The club thinks marketing is handled. It is not handled. It is just quiet.
We had a club come to us whose own website confused its members. We cut the menu from nine items down to three.
First meeting, they started adding it all back. We had to stop the meeting and remind them why they hired us. An AI would have told them they were geniuses and added all nine back with a smile.
That is the difference. AI agrees with you. People who know the work tell you the truth.
And I understand why it sells. AI is the ultimate shiny new object in business, because it relieves you of the thing you do not understand and never wanted to learn.
Nobody wakes up wanting to learn sponsorship, or hiring, or their own numbers. Then a button shows up and promises you never have to. Of course people push it. They are pushing buttons like robots, and calling it a strategy.
Marketing has run this scam before. Twenty years ago it was SEO - page one in a week, forever, just sign here. It was not true. People just did not know enough yet to know it was not true. AI is the same moment, bigger and faster.
Here is what worries me. It is not just marketing anymore. It is the whole building.
It is writing your job posts and screening your people. It is answering your members at midnight, badly, in your name.
It is building your program schedule and your sponsor deck and your member emails. It is doing your numbers, or telling you it did them.
At Facility Ally we ask every owner the same question: where is your facility leaking revenue?
Lately I have started asking a second one. How many of those leaks did you open yourself, the day you handed the work to AI and never checked it?
Because that is the real Operator Gap now. Not the distance between a facility that was built and one that is actually operated - although that gap is still where the money goes.
It is the distance between the owner who uses these tools and the owner the tools are using.
We built the Operator Scorecard to find the leaks. Twenty-six questions. Eight pillars - positioning, programming, sponsorship, sales, marketing, operations, team, finance. Three minutes. It tells you where your facility is leaking revenue and where you are solid.
These days, half the leaks it finds have a chatbot standing next to them, holding the door.
Now the receipts, because this is not a vibe. This is arithmetic.
ChatGPT alone is up over 900 million users a week. Google now puts an AI answer at the top of somewhere between a quarter and 40 percent of all searches, depending on whose count you trust. And 58 percent of Google searches now end with no click at all.
The answer on the screen is the whole ballgame. If you are not in the answer, you are not in the market.
Translate that into owner. A parent in your town asks AI where her kid should learn tennis. A couple who just moved to the area asks where to play pickleball indoors this winter.
A company planning an outing asks for the best padel club nearby. AI answers all three in one breath - and most of the time nobody clicks anything after.
Whatever it said about you is the entire sales pitch you got. You never knew the conversation happened.
Here is the part almost nobody in this industry understands yet. AI does not rank your pages the way Google did. It builds a picture of your business as an entity - from your website, your listings, your reviews, your coverage, all of it - and then it answers from that picture.
When the picture is thin, or the pieces contradict each other, it fills the gaps. With guesses. Or with your competitor.
The researchers at Princeton who named this field - GEO, generative engine optimization - found that content carrying real statistics, quotations, and citations gets picked up by AI up to 40 percent more.
And in a study of more than a million Google AI answers, about 60 percent of the sources AI cited were not in Google's top ten results at all. Read that again.
You can rank fine and still be invisible to the machine your next member asks.
This is measurable work. Citations. Mentions. Referral traffic from the models themselves. We track it in real dollars. That is the difference between knowing the terms and knowing the work.
I run growth at Facility Ally. Here is our position, and I will put it as plainly as I can.
We have AI figured out.
From a marketing standpoint and a business standpoint. We use it every day - the agents, the models, the data tools. It reads a club's numbers and finds where the funnel is breaking. It does the research, the crunching, the first drafts, the speed work.
We have built our reporting so we can see, in real dollars, what business AI itself sends a facility. We know how to get a club found by it.
And we know exactly where it stops.
It does not decide who your facility is for. It does not build a program worth coming back for.
It does not sit across from a sponsor and earn six figures.
It does not turn an interested person into a paying member, keep your best people, or run your building when you are not in it. It does not know your numbers for you.
That work is still people. It always was.
And it does not matter what phase you are in.
Breaking ground? AI is already telling your market a story about a club that has not opened yet, built out of your permits, your press, and your half-finished website.
Opened last year? You are fighting for members against clubs with ten years of reviews and coverage behind them, and the machine counts all of it.
Been there ten years? A decade of reputation can get summarized by a model in one sentence. If that sentence is wrong, or five years out of date, that is the sentence your next member believes.
One sport, two sports, three sports. Tennis, pickleball, padel. The phase and the mix do not change the mechanic. Your next member asks a machine first.
So here is the offer.
Give us an hour, and we will show you what AI says about your club.
This is not a branding exercise. It is a member you either get or never know you lost.
We ask ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini, and Google's AI the questions your future members are already asking. Best indoor pickleball near you. Padel lessons for beginners. Youth tennis that is actually good.
We write down exactly what comes back - whether you show up, what it says about you, and who it recommends instead of you.
Then we look under the hood at what your website is feeding them, and we walk you through all of it, in plain English, with the fix list.
The industry term for this work is GEO - generative engine optimization. You will also see it called AI SEO, or LLMO. GEO is the one that stuck.
We just call it checking your front door. Because that is what AI is now - the front door to your facility. Most clubs have never walked through it to see what is on the other side.
First step is the hour. Book it at mike@facilityally.com - tell me your club and your market, and we will run it before we talk.
And if you want the whole building and not just the front door, take the Operator Scorecard. Twenty-six questions, three minutes. Find the rest of your leaks.
Where I Sit
I am Head of Growth at Facility Ally. My job is the conversations, the positioning, and the growth strategy for the facilities we work with.
I use AI all day, every day. It has never made a diagnosis for me. It has never taken a position for me. It has never decided a single thing that mattered.
That is not a knock on the tools. That is just knowing what they are.
If you want a button, there are a thousand guys in a comment thread who will sell you one. If you want it figured out, that is the work we do.
AI. Figured out. That is where we stand at Facility Ally.
Mike




Comments